Skip to main content

Delhi HC raises the bar of burden of proof on the defendant to establish a credible challenge

A decision of the Delhi High Court hints at presumption of validity of the patents, Archana Shanker discusses.

In 3m Innovative v. Venus Safety, the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court hinted at a presumption of validity of the patents holding that the grant of the patent by the IPO and the USPTO heightens the burden for establishing a credible challenge. Variously, the judges summarised the principles governing patentability of an invention and iterated:

  • Merely because the prior art and the subject patent use the same term for a feature does not necessarily mean that the feature is the same.
  • The entire specification and teaching of the prior art must be considered while determining patentability.
  • With IPO and USPTO not finding the patent obvious, the burden is on the defendant to prove otherwise.

This article was published on Patents Rewind.

Most Recent

News & Insights

VIEW ALL
Thought Leadership
Jul 02, 2025

‘First published on WTR’ By: Safir Anand In summary This article explores the new IP Reforms 3.0 initiative in India and various developments in the

Promising reform aims to modernise IP management and protection in India 
Thought Leadership
Jun 28, 2025

‘First published on WTR’ By: Saif Khan and Prajjwal Kushwaha Legal framework Trademarks Act 1999 The Trademarks Act is the parent statutory regulation

India: lack of court harmonisation in tackling emerging online infringement threats underscores need for further case law
Thought Leadership
May 29, 2025

‘First published on Lexology’ By: Sandhya Singh, Sampada Kapoor and Kritika Gandhi Trademarks play a pivotal role in distinguishing the goods or services

Heir of the Family Trademarks
Thought Leadership
May 15, 2025

‘First published on India Business Law Journal’ By: Pravin Anand, Dr. Ajai Garg and Alvin Antony The ascendancy of large language models (LLMs) has

Navigating the AI frontier: India’s sovereign LLM quest