Skip to main content

The Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs on 7 November 2016 allowed two applications of Pfizer Ireland covering their commercial method for production of Etanercept, dismissing four pre-grant oppositions. The claims were for a method of producing a polypeptide in a large-scale production cell culture over several stages.

The controller determined the claims to be novel, noting that the opponents’ calculations were incorrect. Further oppositions against the claims on the ground of obviousness under 25(1(e) Indian Patents Act 1970 were also dismissed. The controller concluded inventive step and non-obviousness in the method as none of the prior art documents either alone or in combination disclosed or taught the method.  She opined that “all the discussions of the opponent have been made in hindsight which is impermissible in law”.

Contentions that Pfizer’s two claims were not patentably distinct were also dismissed, with the determination that the two did not involve any issue of ever greening or double patenting.

Gitika Suri discusses the decisions on Patents Rewind.

Most Recent

News & Insights

VIEW ALL
News & Updates, Thought Leadership
•
Nov 21, 2026

Patent applications, trademark registrations, design records and intellectual property judgments form an important part of India’s public IP infrastructure.

Who Owns India’s IP Data? Commercial Scraping and Copyright Protection
News & Updates, Thought Leadership
•
Nov 18, 2026

A few seconds of weather footage broadcast in New Delhi ended up at the center of a federal copyright lawsuit in California. A news broadcaster based in

Can Foreign Copyright Owners Sue Indian Broadcasters Abroad? The Territorial Reach of Copyright Disputes
News & Updates, Thought Leadership
•
Nov 14, 2026

Generative artificial intelligence systems are trained on large volumes of information, including text, images, news articles and other digital material.

Can AI Training be Copyright Infringement? The ANI v. OpenAI Dispute in India
News & Updates, Thought Leadership
•
Nov 11, 2026

Think about the apps you use every day. Their visual identity is often the first thing you recognise: the arrangement of icons, navigation menus, buttons,

Can You Patent the Look of an App? GUI and Icon Protection in India